Apologetics: From Lecture Halls to Mainstream

Apologetics: From Lecture Halls to Mainstream

It’s no wonder 52% of U.S. adults and teens experience religious doubt when 95% of churchgoers feel unequipped to answer their questions.  The good news is over 50% of America’s teenagers are “very motivated” to learn more about Jesus and 77% express at least some interest.  Sixty-five million American evangelicals report a desire to share their faith, yet they cite a lack of knowledge as the primary barrier.  Few churches still offer Sunday school, evangelism training, and personal discipleship.  What remains – sermons and small groups – aren’t providing adequate biblical literacy for Christians to respond to common objections raised by non-believers.

So where are the spiritually curious, doubters, Nones, Dones (with church) to turn?  Google searches and ChatGPT can’t be counted on for accurate answers to deep theological questions, failing to filter or intentionally misleading.  Given growing mistrust in religious institutions, they’re unlikely to wander into a church service or accept an invitation to attend.  Regardless, it shouldn’t be necessary to get in front of a pastor to hear hard evidence and an informed defense of our faith.  1 Peter 3:15 commands Christ-followers to “always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.”  None are exempt from the Great Commission mandate.  All Christians should be educated at some level in apologetics – armed with solid reasoning, substantiated facts, empirical evidence, experiential learnings, historical context, and other logical arguments for the truth of our Savior and validity of our Scripture.

The Problem…Equipping the Few

We should meet non-Christians where they are – in our homes, neighborhoods, and workplaces – bringing the Gospel to them.  Yet only 52% of born-again believers have witnessed to someone at least once in the past year and 95% have never led someone to Christ.  Equally concerning is the finding that over 1/2 see their faith as “private”.  Those numbers would look dramatically different if churchgoers were confident in their ability to speak openly about what they believe no matter what rebuttals came their way.  Now is the time to act – taking advantage of the revival we’re witnessing among America’s youth, particularly Gen Z men.  They’re eager to share their newfound faith in Jesus but aren’t receiving the apologetics training needed to convince and captivate the sceptics and cynics of their generation.

In other words, the knowledge gap between church and seminary is widening – at the worst possible time.  We need more theological education in our churches, when most are providing less.  We should restore and return to traditional methods, while availing ourselves of new innovative technologies, for helping church members overcome fears of being asked questions they can’t answer.  Relegating the congregation’s role to extending invitations so “professionals” can assume our evangelistic responsibilities may attract and retain consumers.  However, a church’s mission should be to equip and send disciples out onto the (mission) field, not spectators but players, who then bring those they’ve led to Christ into a holy place of worship.

Apologetics shouldn’t be reserved for the few – like pastors and YouTube evangelists.  While apologetic resources exist, the space is highly individualized and personality-driven.  It’s daunting for the average believer to attain the perceived status or replicate the presumed role of “apologist”.  The larger the knowledge gap between pastors and congregants (and high-profile apologists and crowds) the more likely it is they’re trying to build an organization, a brand, or a following.  Fostering dependence by retaining the keys to knowledge (the Kingdom) is reminiscent of the religious elitism Jesus confronted.  The foundational principles of apologetics normally acquired at seminary should be made available to the masses.  What if we redefined the modern understanding of the term “apologist”, made it less exclusive, and equipped millions to fit the new definition?  Not everyone is called, but all are commissioned.

The Barrier…Engaging the Church

Two other terms redefined by contemporary church growth models have contributed to the exclusivity of apologetics – “church” and its target “customer”.  Church is not a place or pastors – it’s the “ekklesia” or gathering of “called out ones”.  As the embodiment of “church”, members cannot also be its “customer”.  Instead, they should be considered Kingdom “employees” to train and deploy to pursue the actual, intended “customer” that Jesus defined in His mission statement (the lost, ill, poor, and persecuted outside the “4 walls”).  No company would send out untrained representatives into the marketplace, yet that’s what most churches do every week.  We occupy a small footprint when we centralize around an institution, but we take ground for the Kingdom when we decentralize operations.  Until churches identify and pursue the right “customer”, they won’t prepare members well to serve as “apologists” between Sundays.

Are the barriers to teaching apologetics in today’s busy consumer culture too significant to overcome?  Are Christians too conditioned by decades of abdicating evangelism and discipleship to pastors?  Are we willing to reclaim our rightful responsibilities to learn and convey the reasoning, evidence, and defense against typical objections advanced by atheists or Muslims – and do so “with gentleness and respect”?  Do American churchgoers have the discipline for the level of discipleship required to understand the Cosmological, Teleological, Ontological, Historical, and Experiential arguments for our faith in light of the philosophical and cultural challenges of our day?  How much education would be necessary to teach Christians responses to the usual questions about the existence of God (classical), the reliability of the Bible or proof of the resurrection of Jesus (evidential), and support for our worldview as it relates to topics like of the problem of evil (presuppositional)?  Churches have done away with Sunday schools and evangelism training for a reason.  Those expectations were likely too lofty for the consumeristic palates of American churchgoers.  Yet what matters is not our expectations or our pastor’s, but the Lord’s.

The Solution…Empowering the Many

Deep training in apologetics today is reserved primarily for seminary students.  Yet seminaries are becoming increasingly inaccessible due to rising costs and the time-intensive nature of formal degrees.  Simultaneously, the number of pastors and church leaders completing seminary education is declining.  If Uber disintermediated taxis, and Airbnb did the same for hotels, is it time to disintermediate seminary?  Hotels and taxis still exist, preferred by customers seeking those experiences and that level of service – and seminaries, although many are struggling, will continue to play a valuable role in molding and shaping spiritual leaders.  However, modern technology and tools have the potential to provide direct access for all Christians to curated and expert theological knowledge – conveniently and affordably.  “Outdated” models aren’t reaching a digital-first generation that reads fewer printed books.  Learning styles are shifting.  Youth and young adults tend toward online channels.  Gen Z and Millennials are seeking answers to “Why does God allow suffering?” in a format and medium that fits their mobile lifestyles.  Small group leaders need “just-in-time” theological insights to answer tough questions from their members.  The urgency of those evolving needs may compete with reluctance to challenge the “establishment” (publishers and educators) with a disintermediated, decentralized solution for disseminating knowledge and materials some may consider proprietary.

Despite those challenges, we intend to develop a DIY, on-demand alternative to the time and cost commitment of a seminary education.  We sense a latent hunger for “Seminary-lite” among Christians lacking confidence in their capability to take a strong, informed stand for what they believe.  We’re responding to a growing dissatisfaction among faithful Christ-followers with how much they’ve been taught on Sundays or are able to discover on their own.  We want to help churches and apologists equip a broad base of ambassadors to contend for the faith with unprecedented clarity and conviction.  Modern tools like Learning Management Systems and carefully-controlled AI could provide a new center of gravity for dissemination of curated apologetics information – transitioning from the sanctuary and library to the phone and laptop.  In some Christian circles, AI is considered a potential threat – but, used properly, it could help fulfill a prophetic, transformative mission.  A solution training AI only on vetted apologetics content from renowned scholars could overcome issues of accessibility, cost, and unfiltered results from search engines and AI queries.

In considering our approach to designing an apologetics platform, we debated either “reaching the lost” or “equipping the found”.  Since relationships are the best way to get through to those who don’t know Jesus, we feel “equipping the found” will be more effective.  Christians trained in apologetics would do a better job of convincing non-believers to follow Jesus than AI trained in apologetics.  Atheists or those who practice other religions are also unlikely to be frequent users of an explicitly Christian evangelistic tool.  We plan to transform reluctant churchgoers into evangelistic disciples, bridging the growing chasm (pictured above) between church and seminary.  Closing that second gap (through a curated theological and apologetics curriculum) will cross the first chasm (between non-Christians and churches).  In other words, we are investing in AI to teach apologetics to Christians rather than building systems that execute apologetics with non-Christians.  Imagine the leverage and impact of millions of confident apologists knowing how to share and defend what they believe, forming (or growing) relationships with those inaccessible to the Church and Christian tech.

It’s Your Turn…

How do think AI could be utilized along the continuum above to help turn adamant non-believers into faithful Christ-followers?

Tags

14 Responses

  1. Thank you Jim for helping pastors and church leaders reimagine a discipleship that produces relational evangelism from all members, not merely the few who are gifted or passionate.

    We have settled in our easy chairs thinking our church is ready anytime (Almost) anyone wants to get right with God.

    It is time to recenter Christ into all we do; it is the one thing that changes every thing.

    https://reimaginenetwork.ning.com/recenter-christ-now

    Thank you for speaking truth clearly and compassionately.

  2. Spot on, relevant and timely!
    Great blog post, Jim, that resonates with our project!

    Gibbs Wilson
    Past Chair NCF-Tampa Bay

  3. Thanks Jim for the article. I’m teaching how to Love our Neighbors next week at a church. I’m going to use some of your figures !!

  4. Pour deeply into the few who will obey no matter what the cost!!!! The outcome of that quality of disciple is multiplication. Keep doing what you are doing, you will get better at it. Tools are needed. Thank you for doing what you are doing. Lee Wood A disciple

  5. Exciting and incredibly timely post and project!
    Couldn’t agree more with equipping the found. The relationship ultimately needs to be personal to person., not a seeker to AI.
    I think many of the found these days are missing a sense of purpose and vision for why God not only saved them, but called them. For each of us are called as well to bring about His Kindgom here on earth as it is in Heaven and as you shared, be an ambassador for His Kindgom.
    One of my evangelism professors opened class with the question “what is the one thing we get to do in this life that we won’t be able to in heaven?” Being a part of sharing the good news of Christ and leading others to Him.
    That is why we are here and I love how this project could really help reclaim that vision the ‘found’ need.

  6. Jim, as usual, you speak truth into our modern church issues. Every church desires to make disciples, but most struggle to effectively do so. Technology and tools can be used for good or bad. Too often, the enemy exploits technology and tools to the point that people don’t trust them for any positive value. AI is the new frontier. Thank you for seeking ways to leverage the power of AI in a healthy, constructive, safe, and life-changing way. Great work!

  7. Jim, you hit the nail on the head. This project is absolutley critical for the progression of tools to equip the Church. Very excited to see this progress!

  8. Jim – I have always loved your passion to get in the field and plow, instead of sitting on the sidelines and critiquing others. You have always been on the forefront of leveraging your God given skills in business and technology to help build and grow HIs Kingdom and Church.

    Thank you for the call to action and all you are doing. I am blessed to be living in this day and age with you…it is an honor to plow the harvest alongside you.

  9. Jim,

    Thanks for sharing. I believe you are on to something and think AI could be a great way to help facilitate Apologetics teaching. Imagine having the top questions available to select and then directing the forum of explanation (debate, lecture, etc.). You could have quizzes at the end to solidify the understanding and Apologetics Certifications for certain levels. I’m certain these concepts are already going through your mind as you incorporate LMS, but AI could really add a different level of engagement. Nice work brother!

  10. Amen! I am in. We all should be “apologists”. “What if we redefined the modern understanding of the term “apologist”, made it less exclusive, and equipped millions to fit the new definition? Not everyone is called, but all are commissioned.”

  11. There’s no telling what the Spirit of God will do with people who know they are a reflection of Jesus and who respond in obedience to Jesus’ call to share this truth with others. Having resources like this to equip them is key. I’m encouraged to see this.

  12. Jim: I have read your blog several times and finally I printed it so I could highlight the many different points you make that are critical to becoming a disciple for Christ. You present numerous great points but if forced to pick just one, I can think of no better goal than to “Equip the Found”,
    Based on a model of exponential growth where each Christian brings one person to Christ per year, and those new converts then do the same, it would take approximately 33 years to reach the current world population of over 8 billion people.
    As Christians we need to accept the challenge!

  13. Jim, I believe that closed-minded people aren’t going to let themselves be swayed by anything, and unfortunately it’s usually due to either them clinging to their denial of God’s existence which allows them to believe they’re free from religious constraints against doing whatever they want, or to a bad experience with a church.

    Those who are open-minded and willing to learn however, can be convinced by a non-woke, Christian-based AI platform.

    In an effort to prove this, I logged into Gab AI, which is indeed a Christian-based platform, and asked for support of why I should believe that Jesus is the Christ. It immediately gave me clear believable evidence by reminding us at length that the Apostles who witnessed Jesus’ death and resurrection were willing to die as witnesses of that, adding that men don’t suffer torture and execution for a lie they fabricated.

    Considering that people today must and do rely on technology, I believe we’re fortunate to have one which will backup our being a witness for Jesus.

  14. You’re spot on Jim! There’s a huge gap between curiosity and clarity right now, especially with Gen Z. If AI can be trained on trusted apologetics content, it could completely change how people learn and engage with their faith.

    The real power is in equipping millions of believers to have better conversations in real life. Excited to see everything God is doing at MeetTheNeed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The 5 Steps to Revitalize Your Church

Subscribe to the Blog and Get the Free eBook!

The 5 Steps to Revitalize Your Church

Subscribe to the Blog and Get the Free eBook!

Subscribe to the Meet The Need Blog!

As a Bonus for Subscribing, You'll Also Get This Free eBook.

Root cause for the Church's decline & its path to Revitalization

“Any organization not focused on its customers, or focused on the wrong customers, cannot succeed.” – Jim Morgan